A new book by Bonnie Roskes, titled “Conceptualize, Create,
Communicate -- Designing Living Spaces with SketchUp,” complements my four-part
series, with which you are familiar.
Though there is some overlap between her book and my
series, there are several differences. As a structural engineer, she has been
writing for SketchUp many years, focusing primarily on children in grades
K-12. I am a trained architect and interior designer who has used
SketchUp to convey my design ideas and then publish tips on this blog.
To be fair, I asked a student, a reader of my books and a
co-worker to contribute their opinions about Bonnie’s book. We all agreed
on two points.
First, Bonnie targets interior decorators and furniture
manufacturers more than interior designers and architects. Many of the examples
are how to model tables and sofas while the 3D Warehouse offers thousands of
objects of this type. Interior design demands much more, although I think knowing how to model furniture is very useful .
Second, my fellow reviewers felt that omitting a single
click can be frustrating and found that my step-by-step style makes it easy for
a beginner to master the program. During my 15 years of teaching computer
programs I have found that my procedure -- incorporating concept applications
into memory -- is the correct path to using the software to create new
projects. It allows each person to learn in his or her own way.
Bonnie’s book is interesting in many ways and applies
modeling concepts without going into detail about each click. This is not
my way but it is still useful to know different procedures. Bonnie’s
methodology leaves open the directions to an intermediate level, and sometimes
previous knowledge is needed.
The title Bonnie chose for her book led me, and my fellow
reviewers, to expect spaces rich with ideas on how to use Sketchup for interior
designers. But it does not prove as helpful to architects and designers.
Architects are responsible for designing aesthetically and making sure that the
objectives are the end-use of the building. Engineers are responsible for
applying the principles of engineering science, mathematics and physics to
their design projects. When engineers attempt to design aesthetically they
often come up lacking.
The spiral binding makes manipulation of the book very easy and allow readers to make notes. At the end of each chapter a Model-It-Yourself section is offered where the reader can strengthen the acquired concepts.
The spiral binding makes manipulation of the book very easy and allow readers to make notes. At the end of each chapter a Model-It-Yourself section is offered where the reader can strengthen the acquired concepts.
In the end, there are many readers, different ways to learn
and a variety of writing styles. Bonnie’s book will appeal to many.
